Theodore Roosevelt's 1893 Book Documents Chilling Bigfoot Trapper Attack

Posted Saturday, July 11, 2026

By Squatchable.com staff

So, I just stumbled across something that genuinely gave me chills, and I had to share it with you all immediately. A YouTube channel called Bearly Afraid put together this incredible deep dive into one of the most overlooked pieces of Bigfoot history, and honestly, it's the kind of story that makes you wonder how it ever flew under the radar for this long. The video explores a passage from Theodore Roosevelt's 1893 book, "The Wilderness Hunter." Yes, that Theodore Roosevelt. The Rough Rider. The guy whose face is carved into a mountain. Before any of that, he was a hunter and writer who documented an account that sounds like it was pulled straight from Bigfoot lore. The story centers on a trapper named Balman, a German-born frontiersman who spent years trapping beaver across Idaho and Montana. Roosevelt goes out of his way to establish Balman's credibility, describing him as a weathered, experienced man who didn't scare easily. This wasn't some nervous city dweller spinning yarns around a campfire. This was a hardened mountain man. Balman and his partner set up camp in a remote pass in the Bitterroot Mountains, a rugged stretch along the Idaho-Montana border. The year before, a lone hunter had gone into that same pass and never returned. Prospectors later found his remains scattered and half-eaten. Nobody knew what did it. Nobody went back to investigate. These two went in anyway. What followed reads like a classic Sasquatch encounter report, and it's remarkable that it comes from the 1800s. The first night, they smelled something foul drifting from the timber, something heavy and animalistic that didn't match any creature they knew. Then came the sounds. Movement on two legs. Upright. Deliberate. Heavy enough to crack branches. It circled their camp all night without ever entering the firelight. The next morning, their gear was disturbed and a beaver at one of their traps had been torn apart. Not eaten. Just destroyed. The tracks they found the following day were large, two-legged, heel-to-toe, pressed deep into soft ground. Not human, but moving exactly like a human. On the third day, Balman's partner went downstream to pull the last traps while Balman broke down camp. When Balman returned, the forest had gone completely silent. No birds. No insects. Nothing. He found his partner at the edge of the clearing with a broken neck. Whatever had done it had crouched over the body and left it there, as if making a point. Balman didn't bury him. He didn't gather his gear. He ran for the horses and rode through the afternoon and into the dark. He never went back. Here's what makes this account so compelling to researchers, and what the video really digs into: the behavior described doesn't match any known predator. Every large carnivore in those mountains kills to eat. What Balman described was something that killed and then waited. Something that seemed to want to be understood. Roosevelt himself called it a "goblin story," a polite old-fashioned term for something you simply can't explain. He left room for it being an unusually aggressive bear, but the details don't quite fit that explanation either. And the fact that Roosevelt, a man not known for printing things carelessly, chose to include this account under his own name speaks volumes. What really got me, and what the video emphasizes, is that decades later, Balman still shuddered when telling the story. Not performing. Not putting on a show. Involuntary trembling from a man revisiting something he never managed to leave behind. This account is still in print today, word for word, in "The Wilderness Hunter." For those of us who take this subject seriously, it's one of those historical breadcrumbs that can't easily be dismissed. A future president heard this story firsthand from a credible witness and decided it was worth preserving. The video does a fantastic job walking through the whole account with some atmospheric AI-generated visuals that really set the mood. It's worth every minute of your time if you haven't seen it yet. Go check it out and let me know what you think, because this one is going to stick with me for a while.