Massive Footprints Puzzle Investigators in Oregon Hunter's Disappearance

Posted Wednesday, June 24, 2026

By Squatchable.com staff

So I just stumbled across this video from the Dark Case Society channel on YouTube, and honestly, it's one of those cases that gives you chills. If you haven't seen it yet, you need to go watch it because the details are wild. The video covers the disappearance of Cory Fay, a 17-year-old survival expert who vanished into Oregon's Badger Creek Wilderness back in November 1991. This kid wasn't some weekend camper either. He had professional survival training, knew how to read weather patterns, navigate rough terrain, and handle himself in brutal winter conditions. He was the last person you'd expect to simply vanish. Here's where it gets really interesting for anyone who's spent time studying Sasquatch reports. Cory went on an elk hunting trip with a family friend, and the two separated during an illegal nighttime hunt. When his companion returned to the vehicle, Cory was gone. What followed was one of Oregon's largest search and rescue operations — over 250 personnel, helicopters, trained dogs, the works. They searched for 10 straight days and found absolutely nothing. No footprints, no blood, no signs of struggle. Like he just evaporated into thin air. Then the FBI got involved. Think about that for a second. The FBI doesn't typically show up for ordinary wilderness disappearances. That alone tells you investigators suspected something deeply unusual was going on. Nearly a year later, in September 1992, two hunters stumbled onto Cory's backpack and rifle partially buried in snow and brush. But here's the thing — the location made zero sense. His gear was found nearly 10 miles from where he was last seen, through steep wilderness terrain and deep snow. His jacket was discovered even higher up, along a remote mountain ridge at roughly 6,500 feet elevation. Rescuers were stunned because the area was so isolated that many believed Cory couldn't have possibly traveled there alone in winter conditions. Then came the discovery that changes everything. About a quarter mile from the backpack, searchers found fragments of human skull and a single tooth. That was it. No complete skeleton, no major bones. Most of his clothing was missing entirely — no boots, no pants, no socks. Gone. But the part that really makes this case stand out for those of us who follow Sasquatch research? The massive barefoot footprints found pressed deep into the snow near the scene. Footprints no normal human could have made. The video goes into detail about how these tracks were a major piece of the puzzle that investigators never fully explained to the public. Now, I've covered a lot of strange cases over the years, and this one has all the hallmarks of something that fits into the larger pattern of Sasquatch encounters documented across the Pacific Northwest. Oregon's wilderness areas, particularly the remote mountainous regions, have long been hotspots for credible sighting reports. The Badger Creek Wilderness sits in territory that's been part of the historical range for these beings, with dense forest cover, steep terrain, and the kind of isolation that allows large primates to remain undetected. What makes this case particularly compelling is the behavior pattern. Cory was a trained survivalist who did everything right — he had emergency supplies, thermal protection, navigation tools. Under normal circumstances, that gear should have kept him alive long enough for rescuers to find him. Yet instead of staying near shelter or descending toward safety (which is basic survival protocol), he somehow traveled nearly 10 miles deeper into the wilderness while climbing thousands of feet upward through snow-covered terrain. That's not the behavior of a disoriented human. That's the behavior of someone being driven, or pursued, or following something into terrain they wouldn't have chosen on their own. The video walks through the four major theories that emerged — homicide, hypothermia, animal attack, and the more unusual explanations — and honestly, none of them fully account for the evidence. The footprints alone are the kind of physical evidence that can't be easily dismissed. When you have massive barefoot tracks in snow that no human could have made, in a remote wilderness area with a long history of Sasquatch reports, you're looking at a case that deserves serious consideration alongside the more conventional explanations. The Dark Case Society video does a thorough job laying out the timeline, the investigation, and all the strange details that make this case so unsettling. It's worth watching just to see how many questions remain unanswered after more than three decades. Cases like Cory Fay's are exactly why so many researchers keep digging into the Pacific Northwest's wilderness mysteries. When a trained survivalist vanishes and the only physical evidence left behind includes tracks that don't match any known human or animal in the area, you have to ask the hard questions. And those questions deserve answers, even if those answers challenge what we think we know about what's living in our forests. Go check out the video if you haven't already. It's a reminder that some of the most compelling evidence isn't just blurry photos or fleeting glimpses — sometimes it's the tracks left behind in places where no human should have been walking.